This is a good problem to have: more families want to join your program than you can accommodate. Registration filled up. The waitlist is growing. Parents are emailing asking how to get their kid in.
It's also a problem that's easy to mishandle.
Some programs treat excess demand as pure upside, charging waitlist fees that feel like cash grabs, creating artificial scarcity to justify premium pricing, or making promises they can't keep to families desperate for a spot. Short-term revenue, long-term reputation damage.
Other programs handle it so passively that they leave money on the table and create chaos. No deposits to gauge real interest. No system for converting waitlist families when spots open. Rosters that bloat because saying no feels uncomfortable. The season suffers because capacity planning happened by accident.
There's a middle path: treating demand ethically while running a sustainable operation. Clear policies. Fair pricing. Systems that serve families and protect your program. Waitlists that actually work instead of just collecting names.
Why Waitlist Strategy Matters
A waitlist isn't just a backup list. It's a relationship with families who want to be part of your program and are waiting to find out if they can.
How you manage that relationship shapes their perception of your organization, whether they eventually join or not. Handle it well and they'll feel respected, informed, and eager to participate when their chance comes. Handle it poorly and they'll feel strung along, exploited, or ignored. Those feelings spread through word of mouth.
A good waitlist strategy also protects your operations. It gives you real data about demand. It creates a pipeline for filling spots when families withdraw. It helps you make informed decisions about capacity and growth. Without a system, you're guessing at numbers and scrambling when rosters change.
And yes, there's revenue at stake. Not in a predatory way, but in a realistic way. Families on waitlists represent real demand. Converting that demand efficiently, and pricing it appropriately, is part of running a sustainable program.
Deposits vs. Waitlist Fees: What's the Difference?
These terms get used interchangeably, but they serve different purposes and send different signals.
A deposit is money that applies toward registration if the family gets a spot. It's not an additional cost. It's a commitment that converts to payment. Deposits make sense because they filter out casual interest from genuine intent. A family willing to put down $50 is more likely to follow through than a family who just added their name to a list.
A waitlist fee is money charged just for being on the waitlist, separate from registration costs. It doesn't apply toward anything. It's pure revenue from families who may never get to participate.
Deposits are generally defensible and useful. They gauge real demand, reduce no-shows when spots open, and don't cost families anything extra if they eventually join.
Waitlist fees are harder to justify. Charging families for the privilege of maybe getting a spot feels extractive. It monetizes hope without delivering value. Some programs do it, but it risks resentment, especially from families who pay the fee and never get in.
The recommendation: Use deposits, not fees. Make them modest enough to not be a barrier but meaningful enough to signal commitment. Make your refund policy clear: full refund if no spot opens, deposit applies to registration if it does.
Setting the Right Deposit Amount
Too low and it doesn't filter anyone. Too high and it becomes a barrier that excludes families you want to reach.
Consider your registration fee as a baseline. A deposit of 10-20% of registration is typically reasonable. If registration is $300, a $30-50 deposit signals commitment without creating significant financial burden.
For programs serving lower-income communities, keep deposits minimal or offer deposit waivers for families who need them. The goal is gauging intent, not creating another barrier to access.
Be explicit about what happens to the deposit in every scenario: refunded if no spot opens, applied to registration if one does, forfeited if the family declines an offered spot. No surprises.
Auto-Offers: Speed Matters
When a spot opens, the family next on the waitlist should know immediately. Every hour of delay is an hour they might make other plans, lose interest, or miss the window.
Automate the notification. Most registration platforms can send automatic emails when spots open. Use this feature. Don't rely on manual outreach that depends on someone remembering to check.
Set a response window. "You have 48 hours to complete registration before we move to the next family." This creates appropriate urgency without being unreasonable. Longer windows slow down the process. Shorter windows may not give families enough time to respond.
Make acceptance frictionless. The offer email should include a direct link to complete registration with payment information already on file if possible. Every extra step reduces conversion.
Have a backup plan. If the first family doesn't respond in time, move immediately to the next. Keep going until the spot is filled. Document the sequence so you can answer questions about fairness.
Communicate throughout. Families on the waitlist should receive periodic updates: their position, how the list is moving, what to expect. Silence breeds frustration. Regular communication maintains the relationship even when you don't have a spot to offer.
Roster Caps: The Discipline That Protects Quality
The temptation when demand exceeds supply is to squeeze in a few more kids. What's one or two extra players? Everyone wants to be accommodating.
But roster bloat has real costs. Practice quality suffers when there are too many players for drills to run efficiently. Playing time becomes mathematically impossible to distribute fairly. Coaches get stretched. Parents complain about crowded teams.
Set roster caps based on what you can actually deliver well, not what you can technically fit. A soccer team that plays 7v7 shouldn't carry 16 players unless you have a plan for meaningful participation for all of them.
Once caps are set, hold them. "We're full" is a complete sentence. The waitlist exists precisely for this situation. Families who don't get in this season become your first calls next season.
If demand consistently exceeds capacity, that's a signal to invest in growth: more teams, more coaches, more field time. But growth should be planned and resourced, not reactive roster expansion that degrades the experience.
Late Registration Pricing: Fair or Exploitative?
Some programs charge higher fees for late registration. The logic: it costs more to add families after planning is complete, and scarcity justifies premium pricing.
This can be done ethically or it can feel predatory. The difference is transparency and justification.
Ethical late pricing:
-
Clearly communicated from the start ("Registration is $250 until March 1, $300 after")
-
Justified by real costs (administrative burden, uniform rush orders, schedule disruption)
-
Not so high that it becomes exclusionary
-
Paired with financial assistance for families who need it
Exploitative late pricing:
-
Sprung on families without warning
-
Dramatically higher than standard rates without clear justification
-
Designed to extract maximum revenue from desperate families
-
No accommodation for families with genuine financial constraints
If you're going to charge more for late registration, own it openly. Explain why. Keep the premium modest. And make sure families who discovered your program late but genuinely can't afford the premium have a path to participate.
The Ethical Framework
Every pricing and waitlist decision should pass a simple test: would you be comfortable explaining this policy to a family, in plain language, and having them understand why it's fair?
Deposits that gauge intent and apply to registration? Easy to explain. Families understand commitment.
Waitlist fees that charge for the possibility of participation? Harder to justify. "We charge you for waiting" doesn't feel good.
Auto-offers with clear timelines? Transparent and efficient. Families know what to expect.
Roster caps that protect quality? Defensible. Families may be disappointed, but they understand you're maintaining the experience.
Late fees that reflect real costs? Reasonable if communicated clearly. Families can plan around known deadlines.
Premium pricing just because demand is high? This is where it gets tricky. Markets allow it. Ethics and community relationships may not. Your program exists to serve families, not to extract maximum revenue from their desire to participate.
Converting Waitlist Demand Into Next Season's Growth
A waitlist isn't just this season's overflow. It's data about unmet demand that should inform your planning.
Track how many families end up on waitlists, by age group and division. Track how many convert when spots open. Track how many are still waiting at season's end.
If you consistently have 30 families on waitlists for U10, that's a signal to add U10 capacity next year. If waitlist families rarely convert when offered spots, maybe your communication isn't working or your timeline is too slow.
Reach out to waitlisted families at the end of the season. "We're sorry we couldn't accommodate you this time. We're planning to add capacity for next year. Would you like early notification when registration opens?" Turn this year's disappointment into next year's loyalty.
Communicating With Waitlisted Families
The families on your waitlist are in limbo. They want to participate but can't commit elsewhere because they're hoping you'll have room. That's a stressful position. Your communication should acknowledge it.
At signup: "Thank you for joining our waitlist. You're currently #X on the list. We'll notify you immediately if a spot opens. If no spot opens by [date], we'll confirm that and release you to make other plans."
Periodically: "Just checking in. You're still #X on the waitlist. We've had [number] spots open so far this season. We'll continue to notify you if anything changes."
When the window closes: "We weren't able to offer you a spot this season. We know that's disappointing. We're planning for next season and would love to have your family join us. Here's how to get early access to registration."
When offering a spot: "Great news! A spot has opened on [team]. You have 48 hours to complete registration using this link. If we don't hear from you, we'll offer the spot to the next family on the waitlist."
Every communication should be clear, respectful, and helpful. These are families you want in your program. Treat them that way even when you can't serve them yet.
When to Say No to Revenue
Not every dollar is worth taking.
If a waitlist fee would fund your scholarship program but would also create resentment among families who pay and don't get in, the resentment probably costs more than the revenue gains.
If late registration pricing helps cover real costs but is so high that lower-income families can't participate even when spots exist, you're choosing revenue over access.
If roster expansion would bring in more registration fees but would degrade the experience for everyone already registered, you're sacrificing quality for quantity.
The programs with the strongest long-term positions aren't necessarily the ones maximizing short-term revenue. They're the ones building trust, delivering quality, and creating experiences families want to return to year after year.
Sometimes the right answer is leaving money on the table because the cost of taking it is higher than the benefit.
Building the System
Waitlist strategy isn't a one-time decision. It's an operational system that needs to be documented, communicated, and maintained.
Write down your policies: deposit amounts, refund rules, auto-offer timelines, roster caps, late registration pricing. Put them somewhere staff can reference and families can find.
Train anyone who handles registration. They need to explain policies consistently and handle edge cases appropriately.
Review annually. What worked? What created problems? What should change? Adjust based on evidence, not just intuition.
Communicate proactively. Families should understand how waitlists work before they end up on one. Put the information on your website, in your registration materials, and in your parent handbook.
The goal is a system that families experience as fair, transparent, and well-managed, even when the answer is "we don't have room for you right now." That's the foundation for converting today's waitlisted family into next season's loyal participant.
Ian Goldberg is the CEO of Signature Media and the Editor of the largest and fastest growing sports parenting newsletter. He’s been recognized as an industry expert by the National Alliance for Youth Sports, the US Olympic Committee’s Truesport, and the Aspen Institute's Project Play. Ian is also a suburban NJ sports dad of two teenage daughters and has over 2,000 hours of volunteer time coaching them (which he calls the most fun form of R&D for his newsletter content). Ian and his team provide players, coaches, parents and program directors with the articles and content they need to have a great sports season. Ian has spent most of his career in digital product development and marketing and got his start at the White House where he worked for the economic advisors to two US Presidents.
